A Perfect Steak – Without the Grill!
Steak is just about my favorite food. If money were no object I would probably eat it for breakfast, lunch and dinner.
And I do love grilled steak, but I’m just not a good griller. As something that is outside of the house, the grill falls pretty definitively into my husband’s department. So when I want a delicious and fast steak dinner, I broil it. Here’s how to make the perfect broiled steak. (You may never use your grill again.)
A quick word about choosing your steak: Of course, you’ll want a grass-fed, healthy steak. That means no hormones, no antibiotics, and no feedlots. My favorite cut is a rib eye, but sirloins work well for this recipe, too (and are cheaper). Really, any nicely marbled cut of steak should work. (Learn more about beef cuts here.) The cook times below are for boneless steaks.
Broiled Steak
Serves 4
*About 1.5 pounds of boneless grass-fed steak – For our family of four, I buy one rib eye and one sirloin, approximately equal in weight. (Yes, the kids get cheaper steak. Don’t judge me.) After cooking, I cut each in half and that is more than enough of a serving for us.
*Organic dried rosemary, thyme, onion powder, garlic powder and sea salt
*Freshly ground black pepper (optional)Sprinkle both of the steaks with each of the seasonings, besides the pepper (a gentle sprinkling of salt, pretty generous of the others). Use your hands to rub this in well, then flip the steaks and repeat on the other side. Let the seasoned steaks sit while they come to room temperature.
Position your oven rack to be about five inches from the top, and preheat your broiler as high as it will go. (Mine reaches 500, you may need to slightly adjust the time if yours does not get that hot.)
Meanwhile, preheat a cast iron skillet on your stovetop over high heat. (Mine are small, so I actually use two.) Let it get nice and hot, usually taking about five minutes. (I watch for it to just begin gentle smoking.) If it is well-seasoned, you won’t need to add oil. (If you do, choose a healthy fat with a high smoke point, like coconut oil.)
Once both the pan(s) and broiler are hot, add your steaks to the pans and place the pans under your broiler. (Remember to use a thick oven mitt!) Broil for just five minutes, and then carefully flip the steaks over. Broil for four minutes longer.
Carefully remove the steaks from the oven, and make a small incision to check for doneness, keeping in mind that the steaks will continue to cook a bit out of the oven. These steaks will be perfectly medium rare. If you prefer they be cooked to medium, add them back for just another minute and check again. If you prefer them done more than that, eat chicken instead.
![]()
Sprinkle with freshly ground black pepper, if desired. (It’s better to do this after cooking rather than risk burning the pepper.)
P.S. – A fellow Nourished Living Network blogger, The Prairie Homestead, has a recipe for a very similar steak rub. I’m just a little lazy, but you might like to make a rub ahead of time to keep on hand.
Don’t have a local source for grass-fed meat?
Consider US Wellness Meats, an affiliate of this blog!
You may also like:
*Choosing Safe Cookware
*Last-Minute London Broil Recipe
*In Season: Asparagus
*The Healthiest Meatloaf You’ll Ever Eat, Gluten & Dairy Free (And it’s Delish, Too!)Have You Liked Dishrag Diaries on Facebook?
If not, what are you waiting for?
Extra content like discounts from sponsors, health news and bonus recipes. (Plus we can connect a little more!)
Do You Ever Buy on Amazon
?
Please remember to click through
Dishrag Diaries every time you visit Amazon. (There’s a handy Amazon.com search box in the right-hand column.) You’ll get the very same prices, plus a portion of what you spend will support this site. Thank you!
« previous post
Paleo Bacon Mayonnaise: Na...
It took a couple of attempts, but I think I've nailed the bacon mayonnaise. And boy, is it...
next post »
Wholesome Comfort eBo....
This week I'll be giving away a copy of Kate Tietje's new eBook, Wholesome Comfort. It con...
Leave a Reply
No trackbacks yet.

MmmmMMM, did I make delicious London broil the other night. The best part? It was so quick and easy.
London broil used to describe a method of cooking leaner cuts of beef (or more often, lamb). Nowadays, it more commonly refers to specific cuts that your butcher or farmer will label as London broils, usually top...
Everyone needs to have a recipe for a nourishing and delicious meal that can be made in minutes. Here's mine.
This is also a nice summer soup, as you don't need to heat up your kitchen with hours of simmering.
(By the way, if you remember when I asked you to vote for your most wanted recipe,...
We don't often have corn or cheese here at our house, so when we do we make sure it's super yummy! This recipe fits the bill. Although the Little is currently avoiding most dairy, she can occasionally have goat or sheep milk cheeses, so that's what I chose to use. (They are typically a little...
Is it finally feeling like spring where you are? It is here! I'm so looking forward to this week of warm temperatures and soaking up some vitamin D. Oh, and eating some homemade ice cream!
You are so going to love me for this. So get your clicking finger ready for sharing, or pinning, or whatever...
There really isn't anything quite as comforting as a hot, creamy porridge for breakfast. In our house, making this with real oats is a rare treat. Most often, we'll make grain-free versions. Here, I'll cover the healthiest and yummiest ways to make both.
Oatmeal
Although Dr. Price studied traditional peoples such as the Scots-Highlanders whose diets contained...
I meant to get this delicious recipe out during the heart of winter squash season, but I missed it. Luckily, you can still find some delicious winter squashes, including one of my favorite: butternut squash. Rich in phytonutrients and antioxidants, butternuts also provide potassium, vitamin B6 and folate. And they're sooooo yummy.
This meal pairs butternut...
This is a delicious dish, so full of flavor that you won't mind at all that it doesn't contain wheat pasta. It is grain- and gluten-free, dairy-free, Paleo, Primal and compliant for Whole Life Challenge. (Should I add any more labels? It's egg-free, soy-free, sugar-free... :))
I based this on a recipe I found inside a...
I cannot express how thrilled I am to be reviewing these products. Tessamae's All Natural has got it all: an awesome back-story (started by a mom and her three boys), clean ingredients (check 'em out - not a stinker among them), super cool wax-sealed bottles and most importantly, 100% delicious flavor. Here's why I love...
OK. I'm not going to win any food photography awards. I've accepted this, and now you need to.
In fact, I'm probably never going to remember to take pictures when something has finished baking, or is plated nicely, or otherwise looks perfect. I'm going to always be hopping up in the middle of dinner shouting mild...
Last week my little one was sick. There are many stomach viruses going around, and I guess she finally picked one up. She started throwing up at about 2am one night, and although the total vomiting lasted less than 24 hours, her tummy wasn't quite right for a few days. She was also on and...
Confession #1: I am writing this post solely so I can pin it to my lunch ideas and remember to make this again because it was soooo good. (I'm putting this confession first to compel you to keep reading despite the less-than-tempting picture {It was so pretty in real life!} and despite confessions #2 and...
Yes, I really meant it when I said I'm craving comfort food! It doesn't get any more comforting than chicken pot pie, does it? Here is a delicious grain-free version. It could use a little prettying up - Perhaps you're a better crust flipper than I am? - but don't judge its yumminess by its...
This post has to start with a confession. I am eating this dish for breakfast as I type this. It is so good, I woke up thinking about the leftovers in the fridge.
I don't know about you, but I love traditional Shepherd's Pie. And with these cold, rainy fall days, I've been craving some comfort...
This dinner came out so delicious last night, it cut in line in front of the next few posts I had planned. It came together so quickly and easily, too!
Army SOS is a creamy ground beef dish that supposedly got its name from being a military chow staple. I took my version and made it...
My best friend, who lives all the way on the other side of the world in Ethiopia, is doing the Whole Life Challenge along with me. She's been keeping me on my toes with tons of nutrition and food preparation questions. The other day she was asking me about stock-making, and why the mirepoix (carrots,...
I got some good feedback on the previous recipe-share, so I thought I'd do another, particularly to help out my CrossFit Woodbridge Paleo Challenge peeps. Here are some great recipes to try, presented for free with my comments... You're welcome.
Curried Shrimps and Spinach
Ms. Anita brought this one to my attention, and I will be forever...
So, turns out you guys are pretty indecisive... Everyone voted for more than one recipe, and in the end I was left with a seven-way tie! Oh, well... it's really not such a bad problem to have. Here's the first of the "winners."
Okonomiyaki is a Japanese dish. From what I understand it has regional variations,...
This is one of my absolute favorite spring and summer meals. It is based on a recipe found here at Divine Health.
Now, why can't I just leave well enough alone? Well, one, that's not how I roll. But reason number two is a goodie: You may remember us talking about how certain vegetables should not...
I've got lots of good info for you today! Make sure to check out the yummy recipe at the end (and then you'll see why I'm throwing these random ideas together :)).
Canned Salmon: Why and How to Buy
Canned salmon is the ultimate convenient nutritional powerhouse. It is full of vitamins and minerals, along with wonderful...
Aren't you always looking for great meal ideas? Here are some completely delicious recipes I've played around with lately. With the modifications below (if necessary) they are healthy, grain-free, dairy-free and Paleo. What more could you want?
Hungarian Chicken
Find the original recipe here. I simply omitted the milk, subbed homemade almond flour for the wheat flour,...
Frittata is a real-food version of a pantry-meal. It takes no planning if you have a well stocked freezer and a dozen eggs. It's delicious, nutritious, and you can really put in whatever you have handy. It works for dinner (nice paired with an easy green salad), or is a great lunch, brunch or breakfast....
I usually hesitate to post recipes that require very specific ingredients. Although I do recommend brands that I prefer, I have always hated - even before I was a Real Foodie - when recipe ingredient lists would say "Toll House Chocolate Chips" or "College Inn Broth." Really? The cookies won't set up with store-brand chips?...
I know I've given vegans a hard time. And I will continue to, in one sense, because I truly don't believe that is a healthy way for a human to eat. My own dear sister is a vegetarian, and I hope to change her mind. (Hi, Val!)
But I'll tell you one thing about vegans: They...
When making mayo, ice cream, smoothies - and lots of other yummy treats - we often use egg yolks for texture and a creamy protein boost. But what to do with the leftover whites?
Should You Eat Egg Whites Raw?
While egg yolks (from healthy eggs) are just fine - and actually very nutritious - when eaten...
I still remember the first time I had hummus. I was sitting at an outdoor Mediterranean restaurant on a beautiful evening in Old Town Alexandria, and a friend said I just had to try it. I've been in love ever since.
Hummus is made from garbanzo beans (also called chickpeas), among the most nutritious of all...
Who doesn't love stir-fry? No, really, who? Because that would be insane. Thinly sliced pieces of meat, lots of veggies, yummy sauce... Stir-fry can be a fancy romantic meal for two, a great last-minute weeknight dinner, or just a way to use up random things in the your fridge.
The secret to making great stir-fry out...
I guess I'm on a roll with soups and stews. This is one my family loves. It's super quick, cheap, makes a lot and freezes well. It comes from one of my absolute favorite cookbooks, Simple Food {for winter}. Our bodies crave seasonal eating and this cookbook makes it so easy (and kid-friendly). It's available...
Most of you live in a similar climate to me. And if you do, you know that means one thing: IT IS FREEZING.
Here's something yummy to warm you up.
This is one of those recipes you can't mess up. I promise. So while you might want specifics where I've given you, well, guidelines - trust me,...
One thing I'm always looking to add to my kitchen repertoire is a good fish recipe. I think most fish is delicious when ordered in a restaurant; At home it's more like... edible.
But here's a recipe, adapted from Organic Gardening magazine, that tastes (and presents) like a fine-dining special.
Miso Cod with Spicy Cucumbers
*1/2 cup organic...
Don’t you love summer veggies? If you garden or belong to a CSA, or even shop at a Farmer’s Market and can’t resist a good deal, your kitchen may be overflowing with some of summer’s most prolific producers. Here are some new ways to prepare them.
Is there anything more delicious than a garden-fresh tomato? No,...
Don’t you love summer veggies? If you garden or belong to a CSA, or even shop at a Farmer’s Market and can’t resist a good deal, your kitchen may be overflowing with some of summer’s most prolific producers. Here are some new ways to prepare them.
Joel Salatin once said something to the effect of, "The...
Don't you love summer veggies? If you garden or belong to a CSA, or even shop at a Farmer's Market and can't resist a good deal, your kitchen may be overflowing with some of summer's most prolific producers. Here are some new ways to prepare them.
Today we're going to focus on one particular kind of...
You might remember me mentioning that I have a new favorite, favorite cookbook. I'm thrilled to announce that this week I'm going to be doing a review and GIVEAWAY!! (Well, I guess since I already said it's my favorite, I really stole my own thunder for the "review," which is basically: It's great. Get it.)
Against...
OK, I know what you're thinking: This post would have been helpful about a week and a half ago when I was trying to plan my Real Food Easter meal. At this point, I really don't care what you had for dinner two days ago!
Well, I understand you thinking that. But consider this a very...
This week has NOT gone as planned. I mean, they never do, but this week is really off. It's Thursday, and I haven't done a meal plan at all this week (usually done on Sunday nights), AND I haven't been to the grocery store this week (good thing we don't get much there anymore). So,...
Nothing beats a fresh, juicy orange. My wonderful neighbor, Kerry, recently brought me back some fresh Florida oranges. Although we're just beginning our real growing season up here in Virginia, did you know that we're closer to the end of Florida's orange growing season? In fact, peak production is in December!
Why They Are So Good
You...
...Whatcha got cookin'?
I thought I'd share a couple of things that have been cookin' over at our house lately. Of course, it takes more time to write out my own recipes, so today I'll just share some things I've borrowed from others, with comments, of course. :) Enjoy!
Dee-li-cious Breakfast
Apple Omelets from Mr. Breakfast are sooooo...
I'm up early, looking out on the frozen lake covered with snow, with the fireplace on and my "space heater" kitty cat on my lap. Obviously, this is making me think of just one thing: SOUP! So I thought I'd share one of my favorites with you (closely based on a recipe from Hayden Sears-Livesay).
Curry...
I'm going to do things a little differently today. Let me jump right into the Chili recipe from Kate Tietje's In the Kitchen - Real Food Basics:
Chili
Ingredients:
1/2 lb. kidney beans, soaked overnight
1 lb. grass-fed ground beef
2 Tbsp. olive oil
1/2 small onion, chopped
2 Tbsp. chili powder
1 Tbsp. molasses
2 Tbsp. red wine vinegar
1 tsp. cumin
2 tsp. onion...
Welcome to all of my new subscribers! I'm so happy to have you!
Today is the second day of the promotion for In the Kitchen - Real Food Basics, and I have a great recipe to share with you. But first...
I want to share with you the Table of Contents from the e-book. Take a look...
Although I have always loved cooking and am the sole meal-preparer in my home, there was one thing I never quite got. It amazed me when people would say they cleaned out their fridge and made a soup with "whatever was in there," or that they would cook once and use the leftovers for five...
This past Saturday I attended an Adrenal Fatigue Workshop. Overall, it was very disappointing so I don't have much to share about that, but if you would like some good information on this important topic please click here or here (excellent posts by Modern Alternative Mama and The Healthy Home Economist). (Update on 2/1/2011: Another...








